Disciplining Actions Against the Department Teaching and Non- Teaching
Q. Who
are the disciplining authorities in DepEd?
A. the
disciplining authorities in the Department of Education shall be the
secretary
and the
Regional directors in their respective regions.
The Division Superintendent of
Schools shall
be
the disciplining authorities for administrative action against
non – teaching
personnel in their respective
school divisions.
Q. Supposing the parent Teachers
Associations (PTA) filed before the office of Dr.S the Division superintendent
of the Province of X a complaint for dishonesty against Mr. T, a public school
teacher of Y East Elementary School. Acting on said complaint Superintendent S issues
an order directingMr. A the
Administrative Officer of the Division Office to conduct a fact-finding
investigation on the said complaint. Is the order proper? Why or Why not?
A. No, because the
disciplining authority in the Department of Education for administrative
actions against public school teacher is the Regional Director concerned and
not the Division Superintendent.
Q. supposing the complaint of
dishonesty was filed against the public school principal, would the answer in
the above - mentioned problem be the same?
A. Yes, the answer
would still be the same because the term teacher under Section 1 Rule 1 of the
Rules and Regulations For the Implementation of the Magna Carta for public
School Teachers includes a school principal.
Q. Supposing Dr. R the regional
Director of Caraga issued an Order directing Superintendent S or his/her
representative to conduct a fact-finding investigation on the complaint of the
PTA. On the basis of the said order, Superintendent S in turn issues an order
directing Mr. A the administrative Officer to conduct a fact-finding
investigation on the said complaint, is the order of Superintendent S proper?
A. yes, because the
order of Superintendent S is in compliance with valid order of Director R, who
is the disciplining authority over public school teachers.
Q. Can the Secretary of Education
take action on the said complaint? Why or why not?
A. yes, because he has
jurisdiction over complaint against all personnel of the Department of
Education. The secretary and the Regional Director have concurrent jurisdiction
over administrative complaint against all teaching personnel in the regions and
against non-teaching personnel in the Office of Regional Director.
Q. Can the Ombudsman act on
administrative complaints against public school teachers? Why/
A. yes, because the
authority of the office of the Ombudsman to conduct administrative
investigation is beyond cavil.
Q. Supposing on October 5, 2008. Mr.
C filed before the Office of the ombudsman an administrative complaint for
grave misconduct against Mr. P the principal of X National High School. Can the
Office of the Ombudsman act on said administrative complaint?
A. yes, the office of
the ombudsman has the authority to act on all administrative complaints
Q. Is a Grievance Committee allowed
to hear and decide administrative disciplinary cases?
A. No, because a
grievance committee is not a disciplining authority and also grievance
committee prohibits from hearing and deciding administrative disciplinary cases.
Q. Supposing Ms. M filed a complaint
for disgraceful and immoral conduct against Mr. T, a public school teacher of X
High School Mr. P., the principal of said school convened the School Grievance
Committee composed of Mr. P. Mr. F, the president of the faculty club of said
school and Mrs.S a teacher who is acceptable to both Ms. M and Mr. T After
hearing Ms. M and Mr. T, the school Grievance Committee renders a judgement
finding Mr. T guilty of disgraceful and immoral conduct. Is the judgement
valid?
A. the judgement is
not valid because the grievance committee is not disciplining authority and is
not allowed to hear and decide administrative disciplinary cases.
Q. supposing the Secretary of
education read in the newspaper that a grade VI pupil of a public school was
sexually molested by his teacher Mr. T without any complaint filed against Mr.
T the Secretary issued an order directing Atty. M to conduct a fact-finding
investigation on the alleged sexual molestation of the said pupil. After the
investigation, Atty M recommended that Mr. T be placed under preventive
suspension of 90 calendar days. Finding said recommendation to be in order, the
secretary issues a formal charge against Mr. T and issues an Order for a
fact-finding investigation Valid? Is the formal Charge valid? Is the order of
PREVENTIVE Suspension Valid? Why or Why not?
A. The order for a
fact finding investigation, the formal Charge and the Order of Preventive
Suspension are valid even without a private complaint because under section 3
of the Revised Rules of Procedure administrative proceedings may be commenced
motuproprio by the Secretary of Education and by the other disciplining
authority
Q. May a Regional Director commence
an administrative proceedings motuproprio even without a complaint against
DepEd employees of his regional office and against teaching personnel in his
region?
A. Yes, administrative
proceedings may be commenced motuproprio by the Regional Director against DepEd
employee of his Regional office and against teaching personnel in his region
Q. what shall be the form of the
complaint?
A. A complaint shall
be made under oath and shall be written
in a clear, simple, and concise language so as to inform the person complained
of, about the nature and cause of accusation against him to enable to
intelligently prepare his defense or answer.
Q. supposing Mr.F the father of P a
Grade VI pupil of a public elementary school in Pampanga , filed a complaint
for grave misconduct against Mr. T, a teacher of P. Finding the complaint not
under oath and not written in clear , simple and concise language, Dr. RD, the
Regional Director of Region III issued an Order dismissing the complaint. Is
the Order proper?
A. yes, the order is
proper because under section 4 of the Revised Rules of Procedures, it is
required that the complaint shall be under oath and shall be written in clear,
simple and concise language so as to inform the person complained of about the
nature and cause of accusation against him to enable him to intelligently
prepare his defense or answer.
Q. supposing Mr. P the principal of
a public secondary school in Pampanga filed a complaint for insubordination
against Mr. T a teacher in said school. The complaint did not contain a
certification on non – forum shopping. Findng that said complaint did not
contain said certification, Dr.RD , the Regional Director of Region III issues
an order dismissing the complaint. Is the Order valid? Why or why not?
A. YES, BECAUSE Mr. P
failed to comply with section 5 of th Revised Rules of Procedures which
requires among others that a complaint shall contain a certification in order
to prevent the multiple filing of petitions involving the same issues in other
tribunals or agencies as a form of forum shopping.
Q. When and where may a complaint be
filed?
A. sworn and written
administrative complaint may be filed at any time with the School
Superintendent concerned for cases against non-teaching personnel in their
respective divisions or with the Regional Director concerned for cases against
teachers and against their personnel at their respective regional offices or at
the Legal Division of the Central Office for cases against Presidential
Appointees and employee at the central office.
Q. supposing Mr.A files a complaint
against Mr. T, a public school teacher, for lending money at usurious rate of
interest. What should the Regional Director do with the complaint?
A. It is submitted
that the Regional Director should dismiss outright the complaint for being
without merit since the law on usury has been already been repealed
Q. supposing Mr. P, the principal of
a public secondary school, filed a complaint for insubordination against Mr. T,
a public school teacher of said school. Said complaint is not under oath and
the narration of facts in said complaint does not show the acts allegedly
committed by the person complained of. Furthermore the complaint does ot
contain a certification or statement on non-forum shopping. What shall the
Regional Director do with the complaint?
A. The Regional
Director as the disciplining authority, shall dismiss the complaint since the
same is not in accordance with the required form/or it does not comply the
required content of a complaint
Q. What shall the Disciplining Authority
do with an anonymous complaint?
A. no action shall be
taken on an anonymous complaint unless the Disciplining Authority decides to
adopt the same and file it motuproprio.
Q. when shall the designated
investigation commence the fact-finding investigation?
A. Within 5 days from
receipt of the appointment of an officers of the Department of Education as
investigator the latter shall commence the fact-finding investigation or
preliminary investigation
Q. How shall the designated
investigator commence the fact-finding investigation or preliminary
investigation?
A. By issuing an order
requiring the person complained of to submit within three days from receipt of
the said Order together with a copy of the complaint and the supporting
documents thereof a Counter – affidavit/Comment under oath and the affidavits
of the witnesses of the person complained of with supporting documents, if any.
Q. what shall be the effect if the
person complained of shall fail to submit his Counter-Affidavit?
A. Failure of the
person complained of to submit his Counter Affidavit shall be considered as a
waiver thereof
Q. What is the duration for the
conduct of fact-finding investigation or preliminary investigation?
A. A fact-finding
investigation or preliminary investigation shall commence not later than 5 days
from receipt by the investigators of the Order of the Disciplining authority
appointing him/them as investigators and shall be terminated within thirty (30)
days thereafter
Q. what should the investigation
Report contain?
A. It should contain
the findings and recommendations of the investigators
Q. If a prima facie case is
established during the investigation what shall the Disciplining Authority
issue?
A. If a prima facie
case is established during the investigation the Disciplining Authority shall
issue a formal charge
Q. What does prima facie case mean?
A. A prima facie case
shall mean that there is reasonable ground to believe that the respondent is
probably guilty of the charge against him nd should be investigated accordingly
Q. What is a Formal Charge?
A. The formal charge
shall contain a specification of charge, a brief statement of material or
relevant facts accompanied by certified true copies of documentary evidence. If
any, sworn statement covering the testimony of witnesses, if any, a directive
to answer under oath the charge in writing in not less than seventy-two hours
from receipt thereof, an advice for the respondent to indicate in his answer
whether or not he elects a formal investigation of the charge and a notice that
he is entitled to be assisted by a counsel of his choice
Q. Supposing the Division
Superintendent of Tarlac issues a Formal Charge against a teacher of a public
secondary school in Tarlac for disgraceful and immoral conduct. Is the Formal
Charge valid?
A. No, because the
Disciplining Authority over administrative complaint/cases against public
school teachers is the Regional Director concerned and not the Division
Superintendent
Q. SUPPOSING THE Secretary of
Education issues a formal charge against a public school teacher for
disgraceful and immoral conduct. Is the formal charge valid?
A. Yes, because the
Secretary can take cognizance of any complaint or administrative case filed
before any office of the Department of Education
Q. shall the respondent be given the
opportunity to submit additional evidence if he has already submitted his
comment under oath or counter-affidavit during the Fact-finding Investigation
or preliminary Investigation?
A. If the respondent
has already submitted his comment under oath or Counter-Affidavit during the
Fact Finding Investigation or preliminary investigation, he shall be given the
opportunity to submit additional evidence.
Q. When may a preventive suspension
be issued?
A. Upon motion of the
complainant or motuproprio, the proper Disciplining Authority may issue an
order of Preventive Suspension upon issuance of the Formal Charge immediately
thereafter to any subordinate officer or employee under his authority pending an
investigation. If the charges involve:
a.
dishonesty
b.
oppression
c.
Grave Misconduct
d.
Neglect in the Performance of Duty or
e. If there are reasons to believe that the
respondent is guilty of charges which would warrant his removal from the
service
Q. Supposing Superintendent S issued
an order appointing N, the son of her brother, to work at the Division office
as Accountant Mr. A, the Administrative Officer of the Division Office, filed a
complaint against Superintendent S for Nepotism. After a Fact-finding
investigation on said complaint, the secretary of Education issued a formal
charge and an order of Preventive Suspension for 90 calendar days.
Superintendent S filed a motion for reconsideration asking the secretary to set
aside the Order of Preventive Suspension since the charge does not involve any
of the charges mentioned in section 15 of the Revised Rules of Procedures. The
secretary issued an order denying the Motion for Reconsideration. Is the order
proper?
A. YES, the order is
proper for the following reasons:
1. The
charge of nepotism may be considered as one of the charge falling under section
15 since the penalty for nepotism is dismissal from the service
2. Nepotism
may be considered a grave misconduct
3. Even
if the charge is not one of those mentioned in section 15 nonetheless, under
Section 16 of the Revised Rules of Procedure, an order of Preventive Suspension
may also ebe issued by the Disciplining Authority to temporarily remove the
respondent from the scene of his misfeasance or malfeasance and to preclude the
possibility of exerting undue influence or pressure on the witnesses against
him or tampering of documentary evidence on file with his office
Q. Supposing a public school teacher
is formally charged by the Regional Director for discourtesy in the course of
official duties. The Regional Director also issues an order of Preventive
suspension for 90 calendar days against the public school teacher. Does the
Regional Director commit a grave abuse of discretion in issuing said order of
Preventive Suspension?
A. Yes, because the
Order is without legal basis since the charge against respondent does not
involve any of those charges mentioned in section 15 of the Revised Rules of
Procedure and because there is no reason for the preventive suspension. Even
assuming that respondent will be found liable for discourtesy in the course of
official duty, the penalty for such offense is only reprimand.
Comments
Post a Comment